RSS Feed

Gran Torino: Review


In the past week I saw three of the “big” movies released for the awards season: Slumdog Millionaire, Milk, and Gran Torino. All three were so good that when I say Gran Torino was far and away the best of the bunch, it’s saying a lot.

My daughter told me it was depressing. The Chronicle said it was funny. To me it was neither, but whether depressing, funny, good, or bad, nothing would’ve prevented me from seeing it, because it was set in a Detroit neighborhood with a large Hmong population. As readers of my review of The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down know, I’m fascinated by the Hmong, a nomadic tribe from the hills of Asia. Many Hmong migrated to the U.S. after fighting on “our” side in the Vietnam war; they were subsequently hunted down, tortured, and killed by the Viet Cong after the Americans left. The U.S. government settled them in a few locales, one of which is Detroit.

Gran Torino isn’t funny in any usual sense of the word, but, as the Chronclint capsule review says, Clint Eastwood is often funny as a bitter, bigoted, self-righteous old man who just lost his wife. He snarls, he growls, he aims deadly rays of contempt at stranger and son alike. Sometimes he overdoes it, but for the most part it feels right. Having fought in Korea, and finding himself doomed to an old age surrounded by people he calls “gooks,” Walt mutters or yells out epithets for Asians I’ve never even heard before. Little love is lost between Walt and the old lady next door, who gives as good as she gets, in her language. Neither understands what the other is saying, but these two old coots understand each other very well.

It’s surprising, though completely movie-predictable, when Walt gets involved with the family, guided through their culture by the teenage daughter Sue. It’s the dumplings and noodles that cement the relationship. (It’s always the pasta, isn’t it?)

That Walt comes to a grudging acceptance of a Hmong family is the only   predictable thing that happens: the climax of Gran Torino, and the events leading up to it, come as a surprise, or even shock. To say more about the plot might spoil it, so I’ll just add that, for me, the film was the opposite of depressing — it’s a gorgeous, heroic, and redemptive story.

I’d been curious to see how a Hollywood movie would portray the Hmong. In one scene the camera pans the street, revealing the neighborhood through Walt’s baby blue eyes. He looks with dismay upon one dilapidated house after another — peeling paint, crumbling roofs, unkempt yards.We know, of course, what this means to Walt: that his neighbors are lazy, negligent, morally inferior. What the panning camera can’t show is that the Hmong, nomadic for generations, are mystified by hammers, nails, and home repair; their skills are in cultivating the land, and creating intricate clothing and costumes. Their values are spiritual: they spend a great deal of time enacting rituals, caring for the soul rather than the house and yard. Thus, Sue’s brother Thao is fascinated by Walt’s tools, and hungers to learn how to use them. I couldn’t help but wonder, though, if audiences realize why their homes aren’t well-maintained, or if they leave the theater still seeing the Hmong through Walt’s eyes, believing the dilapidated houses shelter lazy people.

In an entirely different area, I also wonder about Eastwood’s choice in naming his main character Kowalski. Is he echoing Stanley and Stella on purpose? Stanley Kowalski comes off far from heroic at the end of A Streetcar Named Desire. Maybe the naming is a way of placing Walt firmly in the working class; or maybe it’s simply cinematic homage. It might be pure coincidence, but, from what I hear, nothing Clint Eastwood does is coincidental.

GT car

Oh dear. I see I forgot to mention the car…Walt’s precious Gran Torino, from which the movie gets its name. Coveted by everyone, the car plays such a key role in the story that Eastwood made the movie its namsake.

I’d planned on seeing a few more “big” movies this month, but after GT I have no desire to see anything too soon. This is the kind of film I want to process for awhile: I want to let it float around my brain undisturbed, its memory popping up every so often. Sorry, Brad–you should know by now it’s tough to compete with Clint.



10 responses »

  1. Thanks Marcy. I’m thinking about going and seeing it. Is that photo in the middle a photo of people dressed in Hmong clothing (or Hmong people)? I wish I could see it better.

  2. Yes, it’s a group of Hmong in clothes worn for rituals and other special occasions. To see more pictures of Hmong try, a list of Hmong resources

  3. I did not think about the nomadic culture when they panned across the neighborhood. It struck me as odd that they would not keep their houses in the same way as Walt.

  4. That’s what I figured–unless you know something about the Hmong, it wouldn’t occur to anyone that there might be a reason, other than laziness or poverty, for their houses not to be in better shape.That’s what people usually think when they see unkept houses.

  5. That makes sense because of the flood of people wanting things fixed and repaired once he had Thao working for him.
    I keep things on our site pretty anonymous mainly to keep my corporate hr from finding out and limiting what we say and the topics we cover.

  6. Great review–the trailer for GT made me want to see it, and your review just cemented that desire. I heard an interview in which Clint said that he really enjoyed saying the classic old man snarl, “Get off my lawn!” I love Clint, but Brad was pretty good too.

  7. Great review, thanks so much. I saw Gran Torino last week and was truly blown away by the cantankerous Clint. Brad as Benjamin Button was a terrific experience, and I have a sneaky suspicion that the Academy might well pull one of their ‘oh we should have given this to you before so here you go now’ and give the gold to Brad. But Clint was exceptional–which is saying something because he is always exceptional. 😉

    I think they just might give Clint the award because he’s never gotten one for acting, and he is getting on…but that’s okay, since he deserves it.–MS

  8. Did you see the same movie I did?

    Awkward “acting” by the Hmong actors. Cartoonish, one dimensional, character by Eastwood. Cartoonish, one dimensional, portrayal of Eastwood’s sons. Cartoonish, one dimensional, bad guys. Predictable character development towards mutual acceptance and respect.

    And the ending. Too many bullets from too many bad guys for too long.

    And a Gran Turino! I could understand a 442 or a GTO, but a Gran Turino?

    My wife and I saw Milk recently, too. At the end, there was much spontaneous applause. At the end of GT, one person applauded but no one else joined in.

    Judith Crist must be spinning in her grave. Oops, she’s still alive.

  9. Reasonable people can disagree, I guess. It’s still nice to see you here, Michael.–MS

  10. Gran Torino is not Eastwood’s best film as director or actor but it perfectly encapsulates his onscreen persona and his brilliant directorial career. Good review, check out mine when you can!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: